Movie Recommendations

We belong to Netflix and I'm running out of movies to watch. There's nothing in "new releases" that I haven't already rented or want to see. I hate going through a million movies, so I figured I'd ask you wise folks what you'd recommend. Recently saw "In America" which was amazing and sad, "The Station Agent" which was amazing and sad, and "Taking Lives" which was not amazing and sad only because of how badly it sucked. It was actually comical how bad it was. And I check the ratings on www.rottentomatoes.com before renting anything, so that way Robert can't give me shit if I rent something he hates.

Suggestions?